Date: 7./8. September 2017
Venue: Tolmin and Čadrg/Triglav National Park, Slovenia
Organizers: ISCAR, ZRC SAZU
Detailled programme: see below or download here
Here you find the PDFs of the presentations held at the ISCAR Workshop 2018:
Andrea Cottini & Stefania Cerutti
Mojca Golobic & Nadja Penko Seidl
Mateja Smid Hribar & Mimi Urbanc
The titles of the presentations and more information about each speaker can be found in the detailled programme (see below).
LOCAL ORGANIZING COMMITTEE
Mimi Urbanc, Mateja Šmid Hribar, Matej Gabrovec, Primož Gašperič, and Primož Pipan
ZRC SAZU: Anton Melik Geographical Institute, Research Center of Slovenian Academy of Sciences and Arts
The agricultural cultural landscape reflects natural resources and humankind’s past and current activities that have been carried out in the context of wider social, economic, technological, and political conditions. The basic characteristic of the landscape is its dynamics and constant change. The landscape comprises not only tangible (material) elements, but also an intangible (mental or imagined) part. As such, it is recognized as both an ecological and socioeconomic system. It reflects people’s adaptation to natural features and their development of land-use strategies in dynamic and unpredictable social and political developments. Geographical settings in mountainous and hilly regions such as the Alps are especially vulnerable and unstable. Various landscape structures were generated due to this adapted land use and enhanced landscape diversity was increased, which was reflected in a mosaic landscapes. The variety of human activity had a direct impact on both landscape diversity and biodiversity. The alpine landscape thus became cultural heritage and a resource, both important for developing a sense of belonging and identity. Alpine agricultural landscapes offer people the opportunity to learn about traditional knowledge acquired through living in a mountain environment. However, the role it plays in ensuring environmental balance and in the myriad of ecosystem services should also not be ignored.
Farming in the Alps
The importance of preserving traditional agriculture landscapes in the Alps was recognized in the Alpine Convention and its Mountain Farming Protocol, which states that “in mountain regions in particular farming has, over the centuries, shaped the countryside, giving it its historical character and cultural value.” Livestock farming suited to local conditions is not only an important source of revenue, but also a decisive part of the identity of the countryside and culture. Agricultural heritage is an important part of numerous protected areas in the Alps, including national parks. In such areas conservation of natural and cultural heritage linked to sustainable tourism could have a positive impact on regional development.
GIAHS and satoyama
In 2002 the Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO) of the United Nations started an initiative aiming to safeguard and support the world’s Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems (GIAHS). They not only have outstanding landscapes, globally significant agricultural biodiversity, indigenous knowledge, and resilient ecosystems, but also provide a livelihood for millions of family farmers. Safeguarding social, cultural, economic, and environmental goods and services for family farmers, indigenous peoples, and local communities should be of utmost importance. The concept of GIAHS is very close to the Japanese concept of the satoyama landscape. It is based on “socio-ecological production landscapes,” which “are dynamic mosaics of habitats and land use practices that have been shaped over the years by the interactions between people and nature in ways that maintain biodiversity and provide humans with goods and services needed for their well-being” (Paris Declaration on the Satoyama Initiative 2010). These landscapes have multifunctional roles and are important for providing numerous ecosystem services that are identified as all of the benefits that people receive from ecosystems and contribute to human wellbeing.
However, agricultural landscapes have been facing numerous challenges, mostly resulting in their impoverishment and threatening them due to modern social and economic processes. Agriculture in the Alps cannot be competitive on the global market due to less-favorable natural conditions and thus fragile economic feasibility. Additional challenges in rural areas are increased rural –urban migration, a rapidly aging population, and depopulation resulted in overgrowth, shrinkage of agriculture land, and loss of biodiversity. All of these processes lead to the loss of traditional ecological knowledge and practices for cultivating land.
The aim of the workshop is to explore Alpine landscapes that are important for their agricultural heritage and to assess those landscapes that fulfill the criteria for inclusion in Globally Important Agricultural Heritage Systems (GIAHS). For this, it is necessary to clarify the historical dimension of these heritage systems. Besides existing traditional production systems, this workshop will also address the reactivation of former traditional practices and the restoration of traditional landscape elements. In addition, this workshop seeks to identify and compare other good practices in remote Alpine agriculture settlement in protected areas similar to the village of Čadrg and to investigate their contribution to human wellbeing.
Target public, formatThe workshop addresses experts in Alpine agricultural production systems with perspectives on the (cultural) landscape, ecosystems, and socioeconomic systems. To focus the discussion, the workshop will be open to twenty to thirty experts from research and interested stakeholders from various Alpine countries and the Alpine Convention.
Locations in Slovenia
The workshop focuses on Alpine agricultural landscapes as the result of people’s management of arable and forest land, and will take place in Tolmin, which was named Alpine Town of the Year 2016, and partly also in the village of Čadrg in Slovenia’s Triglav National Park. Half a century ago, this mountain settlement was on the brink of dying out due to the lack of a road connection with the valley. Today it serves as an example of successful revitalization of a remote mountain community and its branding as an ecological, agricultural, and tourism destination.
The main findings will be published in a joint research article, and, based on this, the development of a transnational and transdisciplinary project regarding issues from the workshop (e.g., Alpine Space). Depending on the results of the workshop, a pan-alpine approach evaluating potential GIAHS sites in the Alps could be proposed to the Alpine Convention or its working group on mountain framing (e.g., by ISCAR as an official observer).
This workshop is being jointly organized as part of (and has received financial support from) the project Cultural Landscapes Caught between Public Good, Private Interests, and Politics (http://giam.zrc-sazu.si/en/programi-in-projekti/cultural-landscapes-caught-between-public-good-private-interests-and-politics#v), funded as a Slovenian basic research project.
Day 1, September 7th, 2017, 10:00–18:15
Location: Hotel Dvorec, Mestni trg 3, 5220 Tolmin, Slovenia
|10:00–10:30||Registration and refreshments: networking among participants|
|10:30–10:45||Welcome and opening ISCAR (Thomas Scheurer)|
ZRC SAZU (Mimi Urbanc)
Mayor of Tolmin (Uroš Brežan)
|10:45–13:30||Part I: Specific types of agricultural production in the Alps in the context of landscape evolutionModerator: Thomas Scheurer|
|10:45–12:00||Keynote lecture The role of agricultural production systems in landscape evolution PDF PD. Dr. MatthiasBürgi, WSL CH-Birmensdorf|
|12:00–13:00||Short presentations Žiga Zwitter (Ljubljana): 17th and early 19th century practices of grassland management and use in the Julian Alps PDF Špela Ledinek Lozej (Udine): Seasonal mountain pasture systems in the Julian Alps PDF Peter Moser (Berne): Different perceptions of landscapes by the farming population (who creates and changes them continuously through their agricultural practices) and industrial societies since the 19thcentury PDF Andrea Cottini (Domodossola): Good hemp for good practices along the Alps PDF|
|14:15 –16:30||Part II: Alpine agricultural landscapes and the main types of agricultural production systems regarding GIAHSModerator: Matej Gabrovec|
|14:15– 15:30||Keynote lecture Exploring potentials of alpine landscapes in their inclusion in GIAHS PDF Prof. Dr. Mauro Agnoletti, University of Florence|
|15:30–16:30||Short presentations Viviana Ferrario (Venice): Potential GIAHS in the Dolomites. A necessary complement to the WHS PDF Mojca Golobič, Nadja Penko Seidl (Ljubljana): The implications of landscape (in)sensitivity of policies: insights from the evaluation of Common agricultural policy impact on Alpine cultural landscapes in Slovenia PDF Cassiano Luminati (Poschiavo): The agricultural cultural heritage in a UNESCO World Heritage Landscape (Val Poschiavo) PDF|
|17:00 – 18:15||Discussion on Parts I and II Moderator: Mauro Agnoletti|
Day 2, September 8th, 2017, 8:00–15:30
Location: Tourist farm at Lovrč, Čadrg 8, 5220 Tolmin, Triglav National Park, Slovenia
|08:00–09:00||Transport from Tolmin to Čadrg|
|09:00–10:00||A walk through Čadrg Guided tour with Primož Pipan and Ludvik Janež|
|10:00–11:00||Coffee and presentation of the project Cultural Landscapes Caught between Public Good, Private Interests, and Politics (Mimi Urbanc and Mateja Šmid Hribar) PDF|
|11:00–12:00||Part III: Opportunities for the valorization of cultural landscapes: Towards an inventory of historical agricultural production systems in the Alps (GIAHS, UNESCO intangible heritageModerator: Mimi Urbanc, Mateja Šmid Hribar Hiroyuki Ono (FAO): Experience with the GIAHS approach PDF Engelbert Ruoss (Lovadina di Spresiano, Treviso): Agricultural Heritage in UNESCO Designated Sites PDF Drago Kladnik (Ljubljana): Terraced landscapes of the Alps PDF|
|12:00–13:00||Output-oriented group work on selected topics Group on potential research paper (Moderators: Mimi Urbanc and Mateja Šmid Hribar) Group on potential project proposal (Moderators: Špela Ledinek Lozej and Cassiano Luminati) Group on potential Alpine GIAHS sites (Moderator: Thomas Scheurer)|
|14:15– 15:00||Presentations of potential outcomes and future steps|
Moderator: Mimi Urbanc, Špela Ledinek Lozej and Thomas Scheurer
|15:15–15:30||Departure from Čadrg and transport to Tolmin/Ljubljana|